ChatGOT vs Poe: I Tested Both Free and Did the Math

Alen Mack11 min read

In the ChatGOT vs Poe matchup, Poe wins for almost everyone. Both apps let you chat with GPT, Claude, Gemini and other AI models in one place. But when I tested both on free accounts, Poe gave me real answers and ChatGOT gave me a paywall. On paid plans, the same message cost me about 9 to 17 times more on ChatGOT than on Poe. ChatGOT only makes sense if you want a cheap entry plan with image and video tools in the same app, and you send few, very long prompts.

One thing first. ChatGOT has rebranded. Every ChatGOT link now opens HeyTop AI, so in this article "ChatGOT" and "HeyTop" mean the same app.

Here is how the two compare at a glance:

ChatGOT (HeyTop AI)

Poe

Owner

Parallaxis Co., Limited, Hong Kong

Quora

Free use in my test

Free quota 0/0, paywall

300 points, real answers

Cheapest plan

$2.90/month for 1,000 credits

$4.99/month for 10,000 points a day

How you pay

Flat credits per message

Points based on tokens used

Cost of a normal Claude Sonnet 5.5 message

About $0.066

About $0.006

Chat models

23

Far more, plus user-made bots

Extras

Images, video, writer, ChatPDF, browser extension

Custom bots, Compare button, API, images and video

Shows exact cost per reply

No

Yes

How I Tested ChatGOT and Poe

I did not want to compare feature lists from each homepage. I wanted to see what you get when you actually sign up and type something.

So on 7 November 2026, I did this:

  1. Signed in to both apps on fresh free accounts, with no payment card added.

  2. Sent the same simple math question to each model I tested: "A shirt costs $25 after a 20% discount. What was the original price? Answer in one line." The right answer is $31.25.

  3. Opened Poe's Message info screen after each reply to see the exact cost in points and dollars.

  4. Read the credit price of every chat model in HeyTop's model picker, and the official rate card of each matching model on Poe.

  5. Worked out the cost of one normal message on both apps, using the cheapest monthly price per credit or point.

I had already checked HeyTop's free quota on 29 October, 30 October and 5 November while writing our ChatGOT login guide. I checked it again on 7 November for this test.

Test 1: What You Get for Free

This is where the gap first showed up.

Poe gave my new free account 300 points. That sounds small, but cheap models cost very little. Here is what happened:

  • GPT-6 Luna answered "$31.25" correctly in about 1.9 seconds. It cost 2 points.

  • Claude Haiku 5.5 answered "$31.25" correctly. It cost 5 points.

  • Claude Sonnet 5.5 did not answer. A "Subscribe to continue" window said the request needed 1,420 points, and I only had 298 left.

That last one surprised me. Poe's own rate card puts a short Sonnet reply at around 200 points, so I think Poe holds back extra points for a possibly long answer before it sends. Either way, a free account cannot use Sonnet, Opus or the other top models. It can use the cheap ones a lot. At 2 to 5 points per short question, 300 points covers roughly 60 to 150 quick questions on Luna or Haiku.

ChatGOT (HeyTop) gave me nothing to work with. HeyTop's site says new users get daily free credits, and its pricing page has promised 10 free uses a day with a free GPT 5.4 model. On my account the chat box showed "Today's free quota 0/0" on every check, and sending a question opened the upgrade window instead of an answer.

So on free use, Poe wins clearly. It is not a big free plan, but it is a real one.

Test 2: What One Message Really Costs

This is the part most ChatGOT vs Poe comparisons skip, and it matters more than anything else. The two apps charge in very different ways.

How Poe charges: points by the token

Poe charges compute points based on how much text goes in and comes out. Every official bot has a Rates button that shows its price per million tokens. For example, Claude Sonnet 5.5 costs $2.02 per million input tokens and $10.10 per million output tokens. You can check any model yourself, such as Poe's Claude Haiku 5.5 page.

The best part is that Poe shows you the real cost after every reply. Click the three dots under an answer, then Info, and you get a receipt. My Luna answer used 148 input tokens and 42 output tokens and cost $0.000061. My Haiku answer cost $0.00015.

Poe also gives big cache discounts of 90% to 97% on repeated context, which makes long chats cheaper if you reply quickly. We cover the points system in more depth in our Poe AI review.

How ChatGOT charges: flat credits per message

HeyTop shows a fixed credit price next to each model in the picker. A message to Claude Sonnet 5.5 costs 25 credits. A message to GPT-6 Astra or Claude Fable 5.1 costs 100 credits. GPT-6 Luna and Claude Haiku 5.5 cost 2 credits each.

To turn credits into dollars, I used HeyTop's best monthly rate. The Max plan gives 3,000 credits for $7.90, so one credit is about $0.0026.

The same message on both apps

I priced a normal message with 500 tokens in and 500 tokens out. That is about a paragraph of question and a few paragraphs of answer.

Model

Poe

ChatGOT (HeyTop Max)

ChatGOT costs

GPT-6 Astra

$0.027

$0.263

about 10x more

Claude Fable 5.1

$0.030

$0.263

about 9x more

Claude Opus 5.5

$0.012

$0.132

about 11x more

Claude Sonnet 5.5

$0.006

$0.066

about 11x more

GPT-6 Luna

$0.0003

$0.005

about 17x more

My real Luna test makes the gap even bigger. Poe charged $0.000061 for that answer. The same model costs 2 credits on HeyTop, which is about $0.0053. That is about 86 times more for a one-line answer.

When ChatGOT can come out ahead

A flat price has one upside. HeyTop shows the same credit cost no matter how long the message is, while Poe charges more as messages get longer.

For GPT-6 Astra, the two prices meet at around 19,000 tokens in and 2,000 tokens out. That is like pasting a long report of 14,000 words and asking for a long summary. If most of your messages look like that, HeyTop could be the cheaper choice.

But I have to add a warning. HeyTop does not say anywhere I could find whether very long messages cost more credits. And most people send short and medium messages, where Poe is far cheaper.

Plans and Prices Side by Side

Here are the current plans for both apps.

Plan

ChatGOT (HeyTop AI)

Poe

Free

10 uses a day advertised, 0/0 in my test

300 points on my free account

Entry

Pro: $2.90/month, 1,000 credits

$4.99/month, 10,000 points a day

Middle

Max: $7.90/month, 3,000 credits

$19.99/month, 660,000 points a month

Higher

Ultra: $15.90/month, 6,000 credits

$49.99, $99.99 and $249.99 tiers

Yearly

$30, $80 and $160 a year

About 17% off, e.g. $49.99/year for the entry plan

Extra top-ups

Credit packs

Add-on points, about $30 per million

ChatGOT has the lower sticker price. But the sticker price is not the real price.

Take Claude Sonnet 5.5, a strong everyday model. On HeyTop's $7.90 Max plan, 3,000 credits buys about 120 Sonnet messages a month. On Poe's $4.99 plan, 10,000 points a day buys about 50 Sonnet messages a day, or about 1,500 a month if you use it daily. Poe's plan is cheaper and gives you more than 10 times the messages.

One more note on Poe. Its daily and monthly points do not roll over, so unused points are lost. Old ChatGOT subscribers also have their own deal. HeyTop moved the old $9.90 ChatGOT plan to an exclusive Max plan with 4,600 credits, and the old $15.90 plan to an exclusive Ultra plan with 7,200 credits.

Models: Who Has Which AI?

Both apps cover the big names, so model choice is closer than price.

ChatGOT (HeyTop) lists 23 chat models in its picker. These include GPT-6 Astra, GPT-6 Luna, GPT 6.1 Sol, Claude Fable 5.1, Claude Opus 5.5, Claude Sonnet 5.5, Claude Haiku 5.5, Gemini 4 Argon, Gemini 3.8 Flash, Grok 4.7, DeepSeek V4, Kimi K3, GLM 5.3 and MiniMax M3. It also keeps some older models, such as GPT 5.6 and Claude Opus 4.8.

Poe has all of the main models I checked on HeyTop's list, including GPT-6 Astra, GPT-6 Luna, Claude Fable 5.1, Claude Opus 5.5, Claude Sonnet 5.5, Claude Haiku 5.5 and Gemini 4 Argon. On top of the official bots, anyone can build a custom bot with its own prompt, so the full library is much larger.

One small thing I noticed: Poe's upgrade window still listed older models like GPT-5.5 and Claude-Opus-4.7 as selling points, even though the newer ones were live. It did not affect anything, but it shows the sales text lags behind the app.

Features Beyond Chat

This is the one area where ChatGOT has a real argument.

ChatGOT (HeyTop) features:

  • AI image generator, using models like Seedream 5.0, GPT Image 2.5 and Nano Banana 2

  • AI video generator, using models like Kling 4.0 and Wan 3.0

  • AI writer and a presentation maker

  • ChatPDF for chatting with documents

  • A browser sidebar extension for Chrome and Edge

You can see the full tool list on HeyTop's homepage. One feature that is gone: ChatGOT's AI humanizer page now just sends you to HeyTop's upgrade page, as I found when I tested the ChatGOT AI humanizer.

Poe features:

  • Compare buttons under each answer, so you can resend the same question to GPT-6 Astra, Claude Opus 5.5 or Claude Fable 5.1 in one click

  • Custom bots you can build and share

  • Image and video models, priced per use in points

  • File uploads and web search on supported bots

  • An API for developers

  • A clear cost receipt for every message

I liked the Compare buttons a lot. Seeing two models answer the same question side by side is the main reason to use a multi-model app in the first place, and Poe makes it one click.

If image and video tools in one dashboard matter more to you than chat, ChatGOT's mix is more complete out of the box. For chat itself, Poe is the stronger tool.

Trust, Ownership and Privacy

Poe is run by Quora, the well-known question-and-answer site. It has been around for years, has official bots run by model makers such as Anthropic, and its pricing is published bot by bot.

ChatGOT is now HeyTop AI, run by Parallaxis Co., Limited in Hong Kong. Its privacy policy was updated on 16 September 2026. The rebrand itself is not a red flag, but it has left loose ends. Old ChatGOT pages still promise free tools that now redirect, and the advertised free uses did not appear on my account.

Neither app is a direct line to OpenAI, Anthropic or Google. Both pass your messages to the model makers. If you work with sensitive data, read both privacy policies before you paste anything private.

ChatGOT vs Poe: Which One Should You Pick?

Pick Poe if you:

  • Want to try top AI models for free first

  • Send lots of short and medium messages

  • Want to compare answers from different models quickly

  • Like knowing exactly what each message cost

  • Want to build your own bots

Pick ChatGOT (HeyTop) if you:

  • Want the lowest monthly sticker price, at $2.90

  • Need image, video, writing and PDF tools in one place

  • Mostly paste very long documents and want one flat price per message

If neither fits, we tested more options in our list of ChatGOT alternatives, including free ones that need no account.

Our Verdict

After testing both on the same day, our verdict on ChatGOT vs Poe is simple. Poe is the better multi-model app for most people.

It has a free plan that actually answers. It costs about 10 times less per normal message on paid plans. It shows you the exact cost of every reply. And it is run by a company with a long track record.

ChatGOT (HeyTop) is not useless. Its creative tools are broad, and its cheapest plan is cheap. But for chatting with GPT, Claude and Gemini, which is the main job of both apps, you get much more for your money on Poe.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is ChatGOT the same as Poe?

No. They are separate apps from separate companies. ChatGOT, now called HeyTop AI, is run by Parallaxis Co., Limited in Hong Kong. Poe is run by Quora. Both let you use many AI models in one place.

Which is cheaper, ChatGOT or Poe?

ChatGOT has the cheaper entry plan at $2.90 a month. But per message, Poe was about 9 to 17 times cheaper in my test for normal-length messages. Poe's $4.99 plan gave far more Claude Sonnet 5.5 messages than HeyTop's $7.90 Max plan.

Is Poe free to use?

Yes, with limits. My free Poe account had 300 points. That was enough for many short questions on cheap models like GPT-6 Luna and Claude Haiku 5.5, but not for a single Claude Sonnet 5.5 request.

Is ChatGOT free to use?

Not in my test. HeyTop advertises daily free credits, but my account showed a free quota of 0/0 on every check from 29 October to 7 November 2026, and each question opened a paywall.

Why does ChatGOT open HeyTop AI?

ChatGOT has rebranded as HeyTop AI. Its login and tool pages now redirect to HeyTop, and old ChatGOT plans have moved over to HeyTop plans.

Does Poe have Claude and Gemini?

Yes. Poe has official bots for Claude models like Claude Sonnet 5.5, Claude Opus 5.5 and Claude Fable 5.1, plus Gemini 4 Argon and many GPT models.

Can I compare AI models side by side on Poe?

Yes. Under each answer, Poe shows Compare buttons that resend your question to another model, such as GPT-6 Astra or Claude Opus 5.5, so you can see both answers.

Do Poe points roll over?

No. Poe's subscription points do not carry over to the next day or month. Add-on points you buy separately last longer.

ShareXLinkedInReddit

Updated 8 November 2026

Related reading